Why good Muslims may be considered bad Muslims

In the West a Photo: The veil of Islam (youtube.com)

CHARLOTTESeptember 18, 2013 – On November 7, 2012, Robert Spencer of Jihad Watch debated Boston College philosopher, Dr. Peter Kreeft, on the topic Is the Only Good Muslim a Bad Muslim? The title alone was thought provoking using the premise that in the eyes of a Westerner a “good” Muslim is considered a “bad” Muslim from the point of view of an Islamic extremist.

In daily conversations and media so-called “good” Muslims are typically labeled as “moderates” today.

The debate was moderated by John Zmirak who later wrote a story for Crisis Magazine with his observations about the evening’s event. A full transcript of the conversation can be found at the end of Spencer’s book Not Peace but a Sword: The Great Chasm between Christianity & Islam.

Among the most fascinating aspects of the dialogue was the context of the word “ignorance” which has distinctly different meanings for both sides of the argument. Many observers, be they educated analysts or average Arab citizens on the street, emphasize that much of what drives Islamic extremism is ignorance that is frequently combined with poverty and a submissive mentality.

The word “Islam” itself means “submission” which translates to signify blind obedience, even if it results in death.

Spencer uses a more philosophical approach to his description but his meaning is the same when he writes, “In his absolute and unfettered sovereignty, Allah had doomed the Islamic world to over a millennium of intellectual stagnation and anti-intellectualism. A recurring idea in the Islamic world is that the Qur’an and Sunnah contain all that is needed for the proper functioning of human society, and everything else is either superfluous or heretical.”

That paragraph speaks volumes about the irreconcilable differences between the Arab world and the West for more than 1,400 years.

An article by Hadi Yahmad, chief editor of the Tunisian daily newspaper Al-Haqaiq, expressed a similar view on September 11 when he wrote, “We must acknowledge without shame that we in the Arab and Islamic region have become a breeding ground for terrorists… due to (our) cultural and ideological backwardness.”                                                                                                    

Yahmed continues to chastise the Arab-Islamic mindset by saying it fails to recognize its own weaknesses while blaming others for all that is culturally wrong in Arabic society.  “(How) many of us have never asked themselves (sic) why these horrors, massacres, and cold-blooded murders take place on our lands?! Must we always lay the blame on others, so that we can (continue) to deny (reality), to forget (it) and to wreak vengeance?!…”

It is here that the debate takes on new meaning and the word “ignorance” changes context. Spencer’s analysis of “ignorance” as defined by Western media provides powerful insights as to why it is so difficult to negotiate with the Islamic world.

“The charge that the people are ignorant, rather than simply sinful and rebellious, is noteworthy, for to this day Islamic spokesmen and apologists charge non-Muslims with ignorance, including those who demonstrate that they understand the religion well. The mainstream media present us with surveys alleging that people who dislike Islam or distrust Muslims are simply suffering from a lack of knowledge. This is in line with the Islamic scheme of things; Allah did not send his prophets and revelations so much to save people from sin but to save them from ignorance.”

In this sense, “ignorance” is defined as being “uninformed” rather than “illiterate.” Therein lies a major distinction. Though the terms are frequently used interchangeably, the comparisons are significantly dissimilar.

One final statement by Spencer highlights Western/Islamic differences even further and, again, emphasizes the chasm that is so deep between the two ideologies. “Whatever the reasoning, in Islam God is not a father to human beings. To a pious Muslim, a prayer like the Our Father is utterly alien. He would consider it presumptuous in the extreme to call Allah his Father. Instead, Allah is the master of the universe and human beings are his slaves. The hallmark of Islamic religious observance is external obedience, not likeness with the divine through an interior transformation.”

When dealing with the complexities of today’s Middle East, be it Syria, Egypt, Iraq or any other Islamic country, these are the sort of deeper understandings required to have any realistic hope of dealing with cultures so incompatible with our own.

Even then, the long-term internal tribal relationships among Arabic societies themselves is a snarl of philosophical ideas that is virtually impossible to untangle.

In the simplest of terms, it matters little what an individual Islamist group calls itself, they all trace their roots back to the same source.

Islam is “submission.”

Bob Taylor has been traveling the world for more than 30 years as a writer and award winning television producer focusing on international events, people and cultures around the globe. Taylor is founder of The Magellan Travel Club (www.MagellanTravelClub.com).  

Read more of What in the World and Bob Taylor at The Washington Times Communities

Follow us:  @wtcommunities on Twitter








This article is the copyrighted property of the writer and Communities @ WashingtonTimes.com. Written permission must be obtained before reprint in online or print media. REPRINTING TWTC CONTENT WITHOUT PERMISSION AND/OR PAYMENT IS THEFT AND PUNISHABLE BY LAW.

More from What in the World
blog comments powered by Disqus
Bob Taylor

Bob Taylor has been travel writer for more than three decades. Following a career as an award winning sports producer/anchor, Taylor’s media production business produced marketing presentations for Switzerland Tourism, Rail Europe, the Finnish Tourist Board, Japan Railways Group, the Swedish Travel & Tourism Council and the Swiss Travel System among others. He is founder of The Magellan Travel Club (www.MagellanTravelClub.com) and his goal is to visit 100 countries or more during his lifetime.


Contact Bob Taylor


Please enable pop-ups to use this feature, don't worry you can always turn them off later.

Question of the Day
Photo Galleries
Popular Threads
Powered by Disqus