MLB announces plans for expanded replay for 2014 season

MLB wants to expand replay, but owners, players and umpires still need to vote on it during the off season. Photo: Armando Gallaraga lost his perfect game on this blown call/AP

LOS ANGELES, August 17, 2013 — Major League Baseball announced its plans to start using more instant replay in 2014.

Currently, only homeruns are reviewable. Under the new system, many more plays will be eligible to be reviewed, such as trapped balls and tags at the plate. Balls and strikes will still not be able to be reviewed.

SEE RELATED: The five most disappointing MLB teams in 2013

Each manager will be able to use instant replay one time during the first six innings. If their challenge is upheld, they retain their ability to challenge plays in the first six innings. If their challenge is not upheld, they will have no more challenges until the seventh inning.

From the seventh inning until the end of the game, regardless of extra innings, each manager will have two more challenges. An unused challenge from the first six innings cannot be carried over into the seventh and beyond.

Calls that are challenged will then be reviewed by officials in New York with the results relayed back to the umpires on the field.

Jim Tracy argues a call/AP

SEE RELATED: Yankees only stand to gain from Alex Rodriguez being suspended

Managers will no longer be allowed to argue calls with the umpires that are reviewable by replay. They are still permitted to argue other non-reviewable plays for as long as the umpire is interested in listening. Then normal rules apply when an umpire throws a manager out of a game.

The exact list of reviewable plays has yet to be revealed or even completely determined. Atlanta Braves president John Shuerholz, who is on the committee with Joe Torre and Tony La Russa, said that roughly 89% of the plays you see will be reviewable. One play he said would not be reviewable would be when a batter is hit by a pitch.

For those who have been looking for baseball to use more replays, this is the Holy Grail. Unfortunately, that Holy Grail is still in the planning stages and has yet to be put up for a vote. The owners need to approve instant replay first, which seems to be a forgone conclusion. Next, the players and the umpires have to vote on it. If either group votes against it, then instant replay is dead.

Jeffrey Maier grabbed himself a souvenir in 1996/AP

SEE RELATED: Texas and Detroit should part ways with their cheaters

Most likely the players will approve the expanded replay. The umpires, however, are another story. The umpires are a prideful bunch and do not take kindly to being called out on their calls. The question remains whether or not they would be open to the possibility of being overruled by someone in New York.

One detail that has not been addressed is the amount of time that will be added to the length of the game due to more reviews. The length of the games has been a hot topic in recent years. It would be nice to see baseball implement new rules regarding the speed of play along with the expanded replay.

For instance, batters should not be allowed to walk around after every pitch. Once they are in the box, they are in the box until the end of the at-bat.

Instant replay will not become any clearer until the offseason after the voting. Ideally, this is a step in the right direction. Purists will say replay takes something away from the game, but the bottom line is that the technology is in baseball’s hands and it was only a matter of time before this happened.

Kevin J. Wells is the Sports Editor for the Washington Times Communities and also writes about Major League Baseball and punk rock music. Follow him on Twitter @WellsOnBaseball

This article is the copyrighted property of the writer and Communities @ Written permission must be obtained before reprint in online or print media. REPRINTING TWTC CONTENT WITHOUT PERMISSION AND/OR PAYMENT IS THEFT AND PUNISHABLE BY LAW.

More from Wells On Baseball
blog comments powered by Disqus
Kevin J Wells

Kevin J. Wells was born and raised in the Los Angeles area in a town called Montrose.  He currently plays guitar for and is a founding member of the Los Angeles punk rock band Emmer Effer.  He has worked in a number of different career fields including Behavioral Therapy, Commodities, Insurance, and most recently a food cart in Portland, OR. Kevin has been both a sports and entertainment columnist and editor for The Washington Times Communities since January 2013.

Contact Kevin J Wells


Please enable pop-ups to use this feature, don't worry you can always turn them off later.

Question of the Day
Photo Galleries
Popular Threads
Powered by Disqus