Breaking News
The Washington Times

« back to Movies in Toto

Christian Toto
Bio

Film review: 'The Taking of Pelham 1 2 3'

Wednesday, November 4, 2009 - Movies in Toto by Christian Toto

By Christian Toto - What Would Toto Watch?

Need a clear-cut example of just how movies have changed since the 1970s?

Step right up and rent “The Taking of Pelham 1 2 3,” the remake of the 1974 thriller out this week on DVD.

The new film replaces craggy-faced Walter Matthau with the handsome Denzel Washington, but more importantly it brims with the sort of flashy camera work and hard-charging music that stand in sharp contrast to the meditative movie making of the ’70s.

“Pelham” also happened to be one of the better thrillers of the past summer, but that’s faint praise considering recent letdowns like “Terminator Salvation” and “X-Men Origins: Wolverine.”

“Pelham” 2.0 finds Washington, looking heavier than we’ve ever seen him before, playing Walter Garber, an Everyman subway director who gets dragged into a nightmare scenario.

A charismatic killer named Ryder (John Travolta, sporting a neck tattoo and closely cropped hair) has commandeered a subway train and promises to kill a hostage a minute if he isn’t hand-delivered $10 million dollars and one cent in an hour.

Let the cat and mouse games begin.

The mental battle between Garber and Ryder is the main attraction here, and it’s good enough to make us forgive Hollywood for retooling a classic in the first place.

But the new “Pelham” remains a conflicted creation, a film which brings the requisite New Yawk flavor and character details, but can’t help itself from staging superfluous car crashes.

And while Washington’s character is portrayed as a flawed Average Joe, he eventually becomes your Standard Action Hero just when the screenplay runs out of inspiration.

The film has director Tony Scott’s fingerprints all over it, and that’s rarely a good thing. The “Domino” director can’t stage a single sequence without shaking the camera, monkeying with the film stock or drowning out the drama with overheated music.

Travolta follows Scott’s heavy-handed lead, shouting some of his lines and dropping F-bombs without conviction. The actor maintains such a reservoir of charisma that he still holds the screen with the uber-reliable Washington.

“The Taking of Pelham 1 2 3″ wants to be a gritty thriller and a blockbuster all at once. Only when the film splits the difference does it directly honor the source material.

Chase Squires

2 weeks, 4 days ago

Gotta tell ya, only after this one became a remake did I watch the original ... and the original is a beaut. I really liked it. So when will they remake Casablanca and Ferris Beuller, cause they must be due for a reboot, right? sigh ... TV is better than movies, TV would never remake a classic ... like V .... oh.

Post a new comment | Reply to this comment

Post a new comment

Christian Toto

Christian Toto is a freelance entertainment reporter and film critic with more than a decade of experience in daily newspapers, magazines and the Web. He currently reports for The Washington Times, boxoffice.com, The Denver Post, Denver Magazine, MovieMaker Magazine, HumanEvents.com, PajamasMedia.com and Big Hollywood. His radio commentaries can be heard on WTOP in Washington, D.C., 820 AM in Tampa, Fla. and 94.5 Country in Topeka, Kansas. He is the official film critic for “The Dennis Miller Show" heard nationwide on Westwood One stations. He regularly blogs about film at What Would Toto Watch? and the Denver Film Community Examiner site. He is a member of both the Washington, D.C. Area Film Critics Association and the Denver Film Critics Society.

Contact Christian Toto

Error

Please enable pop-ups to use this feature, don't worry you can always turn them off later.