Turkey's Chief Justice: If that is Islam, I'm no Muslim

Turkish Chief Justice Haşim Kılıç invites Muslims to engage in self-criticism Photo: AP Photo

DALLAS September 29, 2013 – In a lecture entitled “Human Dignity and the Constitution” at Alparslan University, Turkish Chief Justice Haşim Kılıç touched on the violence being perpetrated in Muslim countries and said, “If this is what is means to be a Muslim, then I am no Muslim.” The Chief Justice was attending a ceremony for the opening of the 2013-2014 academic year.

Only rarely does the West get to eavesdrop in on the self-criticism of Middle Eastern countries. In fact, a common complaint here in the West is that Muslim countries are not sufficiently critical of their own shortcomings. However, this perception is, like many perceptions, a skewed view of the truth.

SEE RELATED: Turkish cleric targeted by protests

Chief Justice Kılıç made this very clear yesterday. He said, “If we were to just analyze Muslim countries in particular, such as Pakistan, Afghanistan, or India, and even closer to home, Iraq, Iran, Syria, Egypt, Morocco, Tunisia and Algeria, they are all on fire. They are burning up. It is impossible to speak of human dignity in these places.

We see it every day on television. One day it is a suicide bomber; the next it is a bombing. What kind of culture is this? What kind of faith is this? How can you explain the violence in countries which teach and believe that ‘killing one person is like killing all of humanity while saving one life is like saving all of humanity’.

If this is what it means to be a Muslim, then I am no Muslim. This is impossible.”

This kind of honesty and introspection by Muslims is rarely heard in the West, and it is not often voiced publicly in the Middle East either, which is why Chief Justice Kılıç’s comments made headlines.

SEE RELATED: Turkish protestors make Gezi Park symbol of protest

However, this question, this conversation, this self-doubt is actually rampant in the Muslim world.

There is a Turkish proverb that says, “Stick yourself with the needle before you stick someone else.”

That doesn’t make it easy though. Objective self-evaluation of one’s own culture is always difficult, more so when the application of faith and religion are being criticized. In fact, it can be downright dangerous as hundreds, even thousands, of people have paid with their lives for criticizing the status quo in this part of the world.

Without a conversation of this kind, however, real progress is impossible.

SEE RELATED: Turkish court sentences Fazıl say for tweets

Referring to the recent bombing in Pakistan, Kılıç also criticized violence against non-Muslims. “Where does religion permit one to enter a church, blow it up and kill 80-100 people? How can you explain such violence, such inhumane action with Islam and being a Muslim? There is something wrong here. I am drawing attention to it so that everyone will examine this error more closely. I do not think it is possible that this belief system gives people the right to do such things. This is impossible, but when you look at these violations of (human) rights, you see them in Muslim countries, but not so much in other countries.”

Courageous words in the Middle East. Hopefully, they will not make him the target of radical Islamist groups in his own country.


During the question and answer session following the lecture, the Chief Justice was asked what he regretted most in his career. The answer was telling. “I have been a member of the Supreme Court for 20 years. I have signed verdicts for the closure of 19 political parties. My signature has approved the closure of political parties who hadn’t really done much. Later, I really repented of this. Since 1995, I have not signed any decision to ban parties that simply express their opinions without resorting to terrorism.”

Confession is good for the soul.

Dissent has been muzzled in Turkey for decades. The banning of opposition parties was part of the court’s job description.

After the government’s brutal crackdown on protestors this summer, Prime Minister Erdoğan is set to unveil his “democracy package” on Monday. There has been a lot of speculation both regarding the contents and the motivation behind it. Maybe the remorse expressed by Chief Justice Kılıç is catching. Let us hope so, for democracy and freedom is one bug Turkey desperately needs.


Luke Montgomery, author of A Deceit To Die For, lived in the Middle East for over a decade. He holds an MA in Linguistics, speaks fluent Turkish and writes on foreign policy, religion and culture. You can follow his work at www.lukemontgomery.net, or find him on Twitter at @LookingFor_Luke and on Facebook.


This article is the copyrighted property of the writer and Communities @ WashingtonTimes.com. Written permission must be obtained before reprint in online or print media. REPRINTING TWTC CONTENT WITHOUT PERMISSION AND/OR PAYMENT IS THEFT AND PUNISHABLE BY LAW.

More from Looking for Luke
blog comments powered by Disqus
Luke Montgomery

Author and researcher Luke Montgomery grew up on the ancient hunting grounds of the Mescalero Apaches, where he cut his teeth on tales of Geronimo’s exploits, supped with Viking heroes in Valhalla and embarked on exhilarating voyages with Odysseus. Somewhere along the way, he grew older, but he didn't grow up. After obtaining his MA in Linguistics, he set a course for adventure in Europe and the Middle East, where he lived for over a decade combing Hittite, Phrygian, Lycian, Greek and Roman ruins on the shores of the Mediterranean and Aegean.   Eventually, he returned to the land of liberty at what he considers its most crucial hour to take up his post in the defense of individual liberty. When he is not consulting private and public institutions with interests and operations in the Middle East, he tends grapes, raises Longhorn cattle and researches public policy, especially as it relates to culture. As an expert on Islam, he spends much of his time researching and writing about religious politics. Some of the people and works that have shaped his worldview are Emily Dickinson, Rudyard Kipling, Atlas Shrugged, C. S. Lewis, Anton Chekhov, Omar Khayyam, LOTR, the Torah, O. Henry, The Ballad of the White Horse, Bruce Cockburn, George Orwell, Yaşar Kemal, Aziz Nesin, Elizabeth Barrett Browning, and Yeshua... You can follow his work at www.lukemontgomery.net/blog.html , or find him on Twitter at LukeM_author and on Facebook



Contact Luke Montgomery


Please enable pop-ups to use this feature, don't worry you can always turn them off later.

Question of the Day
Photo Galleries
Popular Threads
Powered by Disqus