Palestinian economy dangerously dependent on foreign aid

The Hamas-Fatah unity deal and push for unilateral statehood might cut off the money supply, thus ensuring Palestine's fate as a failed state Photo: Associated Press

ISRAEL, May 27, 2011 — For all the enthusiasm of the IMF for Palestinian statehood, the Palestinian Authority remains at least 50%-dependent on foreign donations. The withdrawal of a major portion of that aid would likely result in the collapse of their economy.

The PA’s embrace of Hamas and push for unilateral statehood directly endangers the flow of that aid, and therefore has the potential to ensure the PA’s eventual status as a failed state.

Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas attends a meeting of the Palestinian leadership in the West Bank city of Ramallah, Wednesday, May 25, 2011. (Image: Associated Press)

Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas attends a meeting of the Palestinian leadership in the West Bank city of Ramallah, Wednesday, May 25, 2011. (Image: Associated Press)

 

The international media have been largely mum on this elementary point, but Jon Donnison of the BBC has noticed:

“Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza receive more foreign aid per head of population than any other group of people in the world. According to research done by The Economist magazine, in 2008 it amounted to $675 (£414) per person, per year. A good amount of that money comes from the European Union.

“The EU contributes around 500m euros a year, with roughly the same amount coming from individual member states,” says Christian Berger, the EU representative to the Palestinian territories.

Some observers called it buying economic peace.

And the vast injections of foreign money have seen the Palestinian economy grow. According to the International Monetary Fund, in the West Bank it grew by over 9% in 2010.

The removal or relaxation of some Israeli military checkpoints in the West Bank has also made it easier for Palestinians to do business.”

The BBC piece goes on to discuss the tangible change that has resulted in Ramallah, which has seen an efflorescence of buildings, restaurants and (a little curiously) bars. However, “Most Palestinians cannot afford to come [to Jasmine, a trendy new hot-spot]. The United Nations estimates that 25% of Palestinians live below the poverty line.”

What would happen if the spigot went dry? “Salaries would not be paid,” says Nasser Abdul Karim, an economist at the West Bank’s Bir Zeit University. “Employees would stop spending. People could not pay rent or bank loans or electricity bills. The domino effect would play a major role in crippling the whole economy.”

And how might Hamas’s reentry into the picture affect funding?

“Last time Hamas were in the government, having won parliamentary elections in 2006, the big donors pulled Palestinian funding,” the article notes. “Tens of thousands of people went without salaries for six months. Some politicians in the US Congress are already calling for American aid to stop now that Hamas is back in the frame.”

Okay, American money might dry up. But what about the EU, the PA’s biggest donor?

What, them worry? “At the moment, we’re not talking about Hamas joining a government,” says EU Representative Berger. After all, as he notes, the unity deal is intended to establish an interim government made up of independent politicians. “After that, there will be elections in a year’s time. We’re going to concentrate on what’s happening now — not in a year’s time,” he says.

In this Thursday, Sept. 2, 2010, file photo, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, 2nd left, and Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, 2nd right, are escorted to their seats by Special Envoy George Mitchel (Image: Associated Press)

In this file photo, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, 2nd left, and Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, 2nd right, are escorted to their seats by Special Envoy George Mitchel (Image: Associated Press)

Even the most casual observers are willing to bet that Hamas will be running its slate as independents, an obvious tactic and one to which the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt subscribed throughout the decades that it was outlawed. But, until their candidates self-identify as Hamas, thereby disqualifying themselves, the EU is apparently prepared to turn a blind eye (for a while, at least).

Nevertheless, there are apprehensions in the territories. “During the past few weeks, I have heard a range of words used to describe the scenario if foreign aid were to be cut — from ‘stagnation’ to ‘collapse’ to ‘explosion,’” Donnison writes. 

Nassir Abdul Karim believes the very severity of the likely consequences mitigates the likelihood that an aid cut-off would be so allowed to happen. “The donors are not stupid,” he says. Others, unnamed by Donnison, are equally sanguine. “[If] the big foreign donors did decide to officially cut funding, they would find less transparent channels to keep the money coming, possibly by funneling it through aid agencies and NGOs,” he writes. 

Ah, yes, Good old NGOs.

Judith Levy is a Duke- and Oxford-educated writer with a background in History and International Relations. She was the Soref Research Fellow at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy and has also spent time working in finance as an editor and writer. Judith keeps a blog, judithlevy.com, where she focuses primarily on Israel and its neighborhood. Follow Judith on Twitter:@levyjudith.

 -cl- 5/28/11



This article is the copyrighted property of the writer and Communities @ WashingtonTimes.com. Written permission must be obtained before reprint in online or print media. REPRINTING TWTC CONTENT WITHOUT PERMISSION AND/OR PAYMENT IS THEFT AND PUNISHABLE BY LAW.

More from Israel Online
 
blog comments powered by Disqus
Judith Levy

Duke- and Oxford-educated writer and editor. Judith is a contributing writer at Ricochet.com and keeps a blog, judithlevy.com, where she focuses primarily on Israel and its neighborhood. Follow Judith on Twitter: @levyjudith. 

 

Contact Judith Levy

Error

Please enable pop-ups to use this feature, don't worry you can always turn them off later.

Question of the Day
Featured
Photo Galleries
Popular Threads
Powered by Disqus