Yes, Virginia, there is a Rudolph - but there wasn't always!

Find out the facts behind the fiction about Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer

FORT WORTH, Texas, December 9, 2011 — It’s that time of year again when the spotlight shines once more on holidays, twinkling lights, elves, candy canes and gifts delivered on Christmas Eve by Santa Claus in his sleigh pulled by eight reindeer.

Eight reindeer? What about Rudolph?

Clement C. Moore created the Santa Claus we know and love for the classic poem A Visit from St. Nicholas. The verse mentions eight tiny reindeer, but there’s no mention of a ninth that sports a glowing red nose.

Where did Rudolph come from and how did he come to be part of Christmas? No, not the script for the TV special bearing his name. But who created Rudolph and how did he grow into the beloved Christmas figure we now know?

An email is making its way around the internet containing the true story of how the lead puller of Santa’s sleigh came into existence through the artistic endeavor of Robert L. May. It’s a heartwarming story that includes love, heartbreak, tragedy and triumph.

Does it sound almost too good to be true? Part of it is according to May himself, according to David Emery of and

The heart of the inaccurate story asserts that May’s wife Evelyn died of cancer in December 1938 and that this battle had stripped them of all their savings. The bereaved father couldn’t even afford a Christmas present for their young daughter Barbara.

The little girl wanted to know why her mother had to be different than other mothers. So he decided to write a story to bring her comfort and hope. From this May supposedly created a misfit reindeer that had a shiny red nose.

But according to an interview given by May to the Gettysburg Times in 1975 Rudolph’s conception began on a cold January day in 1939. May was a copywriter with Montgomery Ward in Chicago when his boss asked him to come up with a character and story for the annual Christmas coloring book. The supervisor suggested an animal character similar to storybook figure Ferdinand the Bull. May agreed.

An early Rudolph. Image: AP

Evelyn May did have cancer and four year old Barbara did inspire him. The little girl was fascinated with the deer she saw at the zoo. It was this enchantment, not her mother that inspired May to choose a reindeer for the main character of his parable.

In August of 1939 barely a month after his wife died May finished the final draft of his story.

“I called Barbara and her grandparents into the living room and read it to them,” he later wrote. “In their eyes I could see that the story accomplished what I had hoped.”

This is the story accepted by May’s supervisor and made into the coloring books that were given to children who visited the store that Christmas.

Writer David Emery of tells of the alternate version of this story at He compared May’s account and the version of Ace Collins, author of Stories Behind the Best-Loved Songs of Christmas.

This is the erroneous report making its way around cyberspace now.   

Emery writes that “…while I’m sure it accurately portrays some of the emotions in play, directly contradicts Bob May’s own account of what transpired.”  Emery contacted Collins and asked about the discrepancies between the two stories. Collins stated that his account came to him by way of “’letters and documents supplied by a Montgomery Ward PR person just before the company went out of business in 2001.’”

He also believes his version of the story is “’….as truthful as there is.’”

May’s own children have been asked about the origins of the beloved little reindeer. Their version of Rudolph’s story has always matched their father’s account exactly. Asking May about it now is out of the question though. The former copywriter died at the age of 71 in 1976. agrees with Emery’s findings. It also includes interesting trivia about Rudolph at

After World War II the license for Rudolph was in great demand. But since May created the story as an employee of Montgomery Ward, he didn’t own the copyright. It belonged to the department store. Then in January of 1947, May told company president Sewell Avery about his continued debt due to his wife’s illness. At this news, Avery handed over the copyright and gave May financial security.

Rudolph’s parable was then commercially printed and made into a nine minute cartoon.

Around this time May’s brother-in-law songwriter Johnny Marks took the story and made it into a song. They persuaded singing cowboy Gene Autry to record it in 1949 after artists Bing Crosby and Dinah Shore refused it.

Gene Autry Christmas album

Lo and behold “Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer” was such a success that it became the second most popular song of all time. The first being “White Christmas” by Bing Crosby.

Rudolph’s story doesn’t end there though. There’s more.

May’s own childhood is one source of inspiration for Rudolph’s biography. As a child he often dealt with bullies because of his small stature, slight build and shyness. Hans Christian Andersen’s classic tome The Ugly Duckling was another influence for the famous reindeer.

May’s original classic story differs greatly from the one on TV too.

For instance, Rudolph wasn’t the son of Donner, and didn’t live at the North Pole. He and his parents lived in an average reindeer village somewhere else. And his nose wasn’t a source of embarrassment to them either. They gave him a good self-image and a sense of self-worth.

And finally Rudolph gained Santa’s notice differently from the incident depicted in the Rankin Bass TV special. at  puts it this way:

“…..Santa discovered the red-nosed reindeer quite by accident when he noticed a glow emanating from Rudolph’s room while he was delivering presents to Rudolph’s house. Worried that the thickening fog that night, already the cause of several accidents and delays, would keep him from completing Christmas Eve rounds, Santa tapped Rudolph to lead his team, observing on their return: ’By YOU last night’s journey was actually bossed. Without you, I’m certain we’d all have been lost!’”

Rudolph’s birthday is next month. Here’s to 73 years of that wonderfully glowing nose and looking forward to many, many more.



Read more of Claire’s work at Feed The Mind, Nourish The Soul in the Communities at The Washington Times, her blog Sustenance For The Mind, and the writing group she belongs to at Greater Fort Worth Writers Group. Join her on Facebook at and


This article is the copy written property of the writer and Communities @ Written permission must be obtained before reprint in online or print media.


This article is the copyrighted property of the writer and Communities @ Written permission must be obtained before reprint in online or print media. REPRINTING TWTC CONTENT WITHOUT PERMISSION AND/OR PAYMENT IS THEFT AND PUNISHABLE BY LAW.

More from Feed the Mind, Nourish the Soul
blog comments powered by Disqus
Claire Hickey

Claire has held a Texas Cosmetology License, Certification in Surgical Technology and has decorated cakes professionally. She believes that life is a banquet to be experienced and wants to learn and do as much as possible while she’s here. This Stay @ Home Mom has always loved to write and thanks to the Communities @ The Washington Times has got her chance. Her curiosity and writing lead her to create her column based on “garbage in garbage out” theory to provide interesting and thought provoking pieces that enrich her readers. A proud member and Treasurer for the Greater Fort Worth Writer’s Group she is currently working on her first novel.  


Contact Claire Hickey


Please enable pop-ups to use this feature, don't worry you can always turn them off later.

Question of the Day
Photo Galleries
Popular Threads
Powered by Disqus