COTTO: 'School choice' is child abuse

Why should taxpayers fund droves of dangerous youths being transported to safe, stable schools? Photo: Associated Press

OCALA, Fla., August 8, 2013 — The concept of “school choice” has become a favored cause of social conservatives. The theory is that if parents can take their children out of badly performing schools and send them to better ones, with the school funding going with them, then they will do better in school and the lion’s share of American educational problems will be solved.

More acute observers ought to question both of those outcomes.

SEE RELATED: Guns, public education, and stupidity

School choice will not turn America’s schools into Finland’s and vault American students to the top of the world’s achievement charts. It is impossible for mainly troubled youths in dangerous, let alone underperforming, schools to magically become star pupils once they are placed in a better environment.

What is likely to happen is that these youths will drag gifted and well-directed students into a spiral of chaos and destruction. The problems that plague bad schools, most of them located in impoverished urban environments, will simply be exported to safer city neighborhoods or suburbia.

This is because the core problem with failing schools is not the teachers, or even their unions, as many allege. It is not the buildings or the athletic courts or inadequate funding. It is the student body.  

“I have taught in the Baltimore public school system for the past two decades. What we need is better students,” said Dave Miceli, a Baltimore City Public Schools teacher, in a recent letter to the Sun’s editorial staff.

SEE RELATED: Education and training: A new kind of welfare

“I cannot count the number of students who have physically destroyed property in the schools,” he later wrote. “They have trashed brand new computers, destroyed exit signs, set multiple fires, destroyed many, many lockers, stolen teachers’ school supplies, written their filth on the tops of classroom desks, defecated in bathrooms and stairwells, assaulted teachers (beyond constantly telling them to perform certain impossible acts upon themselves) and refused to do any homework or classwork. Need I go any further?”

Not at all.

Does anybody honestly think that if droves of BCPS students were transferred to successful public schools, or virtually any private ones, in, say, Towson, that their situation would improve? Would these youths become college-bound academics in short order just because their environment has changed?

They would not. What they would probably do, though, is recreate their former environment almost immediately. This would be disastrous for their new classmates. 

SEE RELATED: Obama’s remarks about Catholic schools in Ireland spark debate

Parents pay astronomical sums to private schools so that their children can be formally educated in a safe, sound setting. Contrary to stereotypes, many private school parents are anything but wealthy. They nickel and dime to the hilt so that their kids might have a better life.

This better life does not leave room for the students which Miceli described.

Importing trouble to areas which have none is not only begging, but pleading for disaster. Using school vouchers so that dangerous, self-destructive youths can corrupt the well-being of more productive kids ought to be considered nothing less than child abuse.

This is why starry-eyed center-rightists need to stop dreaming and start thinking. Then, and only then, can the awful truth about school vouchers, often marketed as “school choice,” be considered. 

Far-left? Far-right? Get realRead more from “The Conscience of a Realist” by Joseph F. Cotto 

This article is the copyrighted property of the writer and Communities @ Written permission must be obtained before reprint in online or print media. REPRINTING TWTC CONTENT WITHOUT PERMISSION AND/OR PAYMENT IS THEFT AND PUNISHABLE BY LAW.

More from The Conscience of a Realist
blog comments powered by Disqus
Joseph Cotto

Joseph F. Cotto is a social journalist by trade and student of history by lifestyle choice. He hails from central Florida, writing about political, economic, and social issues of the day. In the past, he was a contributor to Blogcritics Magazine, among other publications. He is currently at work on a book about American society.

Contact Joseph Cotto


Please enable pop-ups to use this feature, don't worry you can always turn them off later.

Question of the Day
Photo Galleries
Popular Threads
Powered by Disqus