Special education versus "regular kids"

LAUSD Superintendent Ramon Cortines says special ed funding takes from regular kids. Does pitting students against students help anyone?

Economic times are tough for a lot of people and institutions these days, and that fiscal reality is no different for school districts across the country. Districts are cutting budgets, eliminating programs, and laying off teachers. It is a shame that school districts have to make these difficult choices, but it is a reality of 2010 that schools are operating on tight budgets.

Los Angeles Unified School District is no different. In an attempt to close a $628-million dollar budget gap, LAUSD will close 200 special education classes as well as a specialized campus for students with disabilities.

This by itself is terrible, but even worse are the words that L.A. schools Superintendent Ramon C. Cortines used to justify this decision. “You have to look at it in perspective,” Cortines is quoted in the Los Angeles Times as saying, “When you fund some of the special ed things, you’re taking from regular kids.”

As a parent living in the DC Metro area, I am unfamiliar with the specifics of the LAUSD’s budget problems. I do know, however, that Cortines’ statement smacks of a belief that so-called “regular” kids deserve an education more than special education kids.

This is not something that most people will say aloud. Most people won’t come right out and say that special education spending takes away from their regular education kids. It is somewhat shocking that a school superintendent, responsible for educating all students in his county would say essentially that.

Let’s put aside Cortine’s use of the term “regular” kids. I am hopeful that he meant regular education children rather than saying that special education kids aren’t regular kids. Because underneath their disabilities, our special needs kids very much are regular kids. They’re different, yes, but every child is different.

The idea that one group of children is more deserving of an education is one that I would hope no longer existed. The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act clarifies that all students with disabilities must be provided a Free Appropriate Public Education. Regular—and gifted—education students should have the same right. That should be a given.

When a school superintendent, through his words, pits these groups against each other, no one wins. The implication is that my student isn’t going to get a proper education because your child is taking all the resources. Division doesn’t help anyone, all it does is foster an atmosphere of animosity. When the students being accused of taking these funds are already the most vulnerable, and are smaller in number, making up 13% of the Los Angeles school population, the air is ripe for an us versus them way of thinking.

LAUSD special education isn’t the only part of the budget that is being cut. Regular education students are facing their own share of devastating cuts. Not personally knowing the situation of the Los Angeles school system, I can’t say whether the proportion of cuts affecting specifically the special education population is appropriate.

What I can say is that Superintendent Cortine’s response to these cuts is not.

Jean is the parent of both special education and regular education children who attend Maryland public schools. You can read her personal blog at Stimeyland or her autism-events website for Montgomery County at AutMont. Follow her on Twitter as @Stimey.

This article is the copyrighted property of the writer and Communities @ WashingtonTimes.com. Written permission must be obtained before reprint in online or print media. REPRINTING TWTC CONTENT WITHOUT PERMISSION AND/OR PAYMENT IS THEFT AND PUNISHABLE BY LAW.

More from Autism Unexpected
blog comments powered by Disqus
Jean Winegardner

When Jean had her first child in 2001, "autism" was about the scariest word she could think of. Six years later when her second child was diagnosed with PDD-NOS, a form of autism, she was just happy to have a word to help him get the services he needed. Her autism journey has been full of tears, laughter, love and at least one attorney.

Jean blogs about her life with her autistic son, Jack, on her blog, Stimeyland. Her two neurotypical children, Sam and Quinn (one older, one younger than Jack), make frequent appearances there as well. Also at Stimeyland? Jean's quirky sense of humor.

She also runs AutMont, an events calendar listing autism-related events in Montgomery County, Maryland.

Raising a child with special needs is hard for so many reasons, but after living with Jack, Jean wouldn't trade him for anything in the world. Come along with Jean as she experiences the joys that come with parenting a special kid.

You can email Jean anytime at stimeyland at gmail dot com or follow her on Twitter, where, as "Stimey," she offers her world view in snippets of 140 characters or less.

Contact Jean Winegardner


Please enable pop-ups to use this feature, don't worry you can always turn them off later.

Question of the Day
Photo Galleries
Popular Threads
Powered by Disqus