Heroic women of 9/11: Where are their memorials?


Comment | Tweet Share | | Email | RSS | More |    
Our collective memory has all-but-erased female heroism from the story  of 9/11. Photo: Associated Press

WASHINGTON, D.C., September 9, 2011 — Close your eyes. Today is 9/11. You're fleeing from a building just struck by a hijacked plane. You've fallen and you begin to feel the rubble from the World Trade Center or Pentagon fall on you.

You're scared when someone begins to unearth you from the dust and debris. When you look at your rescuer's face, what do you see?

For many on that September afternoon, the person who came to their aid, firefighters or rescue workers, military personnel, bystanders, or trained first responders, were women.

But our collective memory and social constructs almost inevitably have erased these brave women from the picture. In our imagined world, strong men were the ones who dove in and, in too many cases, died doing so, in order to save people from the devastation of the greatest attack on our soil in the nation’s history.

It doesn't help that the memorial dedicated to firefighters who lost their lives at Ground Zero includes only men. Nor does it help that another statue reminding us of that day's horrors is of a woman falling, or jumping, from the building. Media commentators are often caught using gendered words such as “firemen” or “policemen” to describe those who assisted on scene or were lost that day. Less frequently, if at all, do they acknowledge the role of women in these professions.

The unspoken reality of the day, as seen through our public rhetoric and collective memory, suggests that women were weak in the moment, they were scared, they gave in. While some did, there were women, too, like Sandy Bradshaw, a flight attendant aboard Flight 93 who originally was alleged to have cowered in the plane's galley as passengers were being held hostage.

President and Mrs. Bush at Flight 93 Memorial

While we will never be able to prove the real story, weeks after that fateful day, an article by reporters of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette told a different version. This one was pieced together from narratives of relatives and friends contacted by the passengers aboard Flight 93, and it conveyed a very different reality of feminine response to terror.

Bradshaw, the reports said, began filling pitchers with boiling water, which most suspect she used to throw on the terrorists who had taken charge of the back of the plane so other passengers could force their way into the hijacked cockpit.

Among them, was most likely flight attendant CeeCee Lyles, a former police officer.

Casting women as heroes outside the home rather than damsels in distress is something our culture still has not become comfortable with. The idea that women cannot face the pressure of real-world disasters in the same tough or courageous way as men is engrained in our worldview from the time we are young children. It’s not a hard argument to make when we’ve never quite made it through an entire Disney movie with a strong female lead who didn’t require some male protection or rescue.

The women who responded as agents or officers aren’t alone in that void. Female carpenters and those women who worked in other professions not typically considered lady-like were also lost that day.

Their stories, irrespective of the tales told by family members and friends, however, are mostly untold and unremembered.

September 11 is not unlike other events where the memories of women performing heroically have been lost to the sands of time. Wars, natural disasters, and other attacks have all claimed the lives of women who often fought to save others, went back, dug in, did their jobs, or followed their instincts.

The female officers of the various police, fire and medical units who arrived at the sites of the 9/11 disaster took on roles that their male colleagues often did not.

Brenda Berkman, a New York City firefighter, was quoted in an article that appeared in the Minneapolis Star Tribune, saying, “Women became the grief counselors and funeral directors, the family liaisons.”

As we remember 9/11 this week and beyond, it is only right that we recall the bravery of both genders, the losses, and the scars that remain.

On this September 11, the story of heroic women will be told at the eleventh hour by CNN in a special called “Beyond Bravery: The Women of 9/11.” This special is based on the book, “Women at Ground Zero: Stories of Courage and Compassion” by Susan Hagen and Mary Carouba.

Maybe it’s time we all give this a read. Until then, this column is dedicated to Sandy Bradshaw and Brenda Berkman, as well as military personnel, police officers, paramedics and firefighters like Sgt. Tamara Thurman, Lt. Col. Karen Wagner, Terri Tobin, Carey Policastro, Kathy Mazza, Moira Smith, Yamel Merino, Regina Wilson, and the countless other women who lived and died on that day of horror, September 11, 2001.

Read more of Amanda Leigh Brozana's work at betweenxandy.blogspot.com. She can be reached via email at betweenxandy.brozana@gmail.com. Her work appears in Smart Living in the Communities at the Washington Times.

 

 

This article is the copywritten property of the writer and Communities @ WashingtonTimes.com. Written permission must be obtained before reprint in online or print media.

REPRINTING TWTC CONTENT WITHOUT PERMISSION AND/OR PAYMENT IS THEFT AND PUNISHABLE BY LAW.

More from
 
blog comments powered by Disqus
Amanda Brozana

Amanda Leigh Brozana is the Communications Director for the National Grange.  She is from Orwigsburg, Pa., and now lives in Washington, D.C. 

Earning her B.A. in Communication Studies from Wilkes University in 2004, her M.A. in Journalism from the University of Mississippi in 2005 and completing her doctoral work in communication at the University of Alabama in 2008, Amanda reclaims her title as a former journalist, focusing on a variety of issues, including the difference between men and women, that she taught classes on as a college professor.

Contact Amanda Brozana

Error

Please enable pop-ups to use this feature, don't worry you can always turn them off later.

Who We Are

This is the Communities at WashingtonTimes.com. Individual contributors are responsible for their content, which is not edited by The Washington Times. Contact Us with questions or comments.

Get The Most Up-To-Date News From The Washington Times Communities.

* required
Most Read
    Featured Neighborhoods
    • The Political Pro-Con

      Not your typical discussion, writer Conor Murphy writes about the cons, and pros, of politics

    • Talking Sense

      We’re human: we don’t always think things through, so we accept many ideas that are, well, ideas that are wrong. We also look past certain truths without recognizing them.

    • Rich like me

      An establishmentarian conservative, short on cash, but long on wisdom.

    • The Tygrrrr Express

      A politically conservative and morally liberal Hebrew alpha male hunts left-wing vipers.

    • Ringside Seat

      Get in the middle of all the action inside and outside the boxing ring.

    Photo Galleries